Fighting on a Different Hill: How we use word of mouth marketing to take on the giants, and win, with ammunition provided by WOMMA
By Rod Brooks, WOMMA Board President & CMO of PEMCO Insurance
The rules of the game have changed. No longer is consumer behavior driven exclusively by traditional marketing and advertising. Today those consumers are making purchasing decisions after hearing the opinions of peers, friends, and even strangers. And most often, those influencers make their opinions known online.
Many smart companies get this, and are taking steps to harness this new venue. Others, regrettably, are still learning the tough lessons of how the game has changed.
Those who are reaping the benefits of these online conversations have made the decision to take the time and dedicate the resources to create long-term relationships with consumers by consistently listening, responding, and joining conversations. Now, smart enterprises are going a step further, giving employees the knowledge of where these conversations are taking place, and the tools and the confidence to join in. These organizations have recognized that engaging with customers in these conversations can be a tremendous equalizer, allowing nimble, adaptive companies to compete on par with much bigger, better funded competitors.
This is the exact experience we have in our organization. PEMCO is a small regional insurance company, and we face national insurance giants spending billions on advertising annually. To break through this advertising assault, we have needed to embrace an engagement strategy that sets us apart from national competitors. We are focused on the voice of the customer, and we’ve decided to spur brand conversations in unexpected ways.
For PEMCO Insurance, the solution was to differentiate ourselves in our ability to connect with consumers on a local level. Our message was simple: we’re different because we live, work, learn and play in the same communities as our customers and understand their needs first-hand.
We created an ad campaign based on this message, celebrating our quirks and shared values here in the Pacific Northwest. The campaign provided entry into both online and offline conversations on topics that matter to our customers – community, local issues, and sometimes even insurance.
As luck would have it, I discovered the annual WOMMA Summit at about the same time that PEMCO’s new “hyper local” campaign was coming to fruition in 2007. Our company was founded on the premise that we differentiate ourselves by enthusiastically embracing the relationship we have with our customers. The “voice of the customer” is so important to us that we are willing to reorganize around their voice and pay specific attention to each and every touch point.
As a self-proclaimed student of WOM, I soaked up everything WOMMA had to offer. I became the “maverick” in our organization and chose to be proactive in our assessment and approach. I found it very useful to encourage our marketing partners (agencies) to become WOMMA members and to take advantage of the information and connections that WOMMA offers.
Together, we spent almost a year identifying relevant online conversations and listening to what customers had to say. We studied other companies’ experiences and brought in a partner dedicated to helping us find ways to use new social media channels in our day-to-day business. Creating “employee readiness” was a key feature of that plan.
We established our own set of social media guidelines to fit our culture and goals. By collaborating with Legal, Human Resources, and Information Security groups, we were able to knock down departmental barriers and roadblocks while converting our skeptics to advocates through the process.
Next, we developed a series of social media boot camps to increase familiarity and comfort with social media applications enterprise-wide. We bolstered our preparation for the training by enrolling our marketing team in WOMMA’s seven-week WOM-COMM 101 certificate program. With the shared vision of rallying around the voice of the customer, we armed employees with the knowledge and tools to meet customer needs in the social space.
Internally, community-building tools like Yammer began with a small pilot group but snowballed organically as employees rushed to get on board. Externally, customer story-sharing tools like Ratings and Reviews provided back office employees direct access to the voice of the customer. For us, these tools have buttressed our customer focus by facilitating receiving, sharing, and heeding customer sentiment across the organization.
Finally, social media leadership summits disseminated ownership of social engagement. Disparate departments convened to discuss the progress of our shared vision and managers were challenged to consider how social media may serve their business purpose.
And we’re not done yet. Our next steps include supporting pilots in customer-facing departments, reviewing and updating our social media guidelines, and offering social media classes through our in-house learning center. The goal is to weave social media into our customer service toolkit – ideally, these online tools will be as familiar as the telephone at every employee’s desk.
We’ve come a long way in equipping our organization with the tools necessary to serve and compete in a virtual world, yet like most journeys, ours is far from finished. By rallying around a shared vision, fostering a social-savvy workforce, and meeting customers on their terms, we can deliver unsurpassed customer service in a marketplace where the rules – and the conversation – are continually changing.
Being a member of WOMMA has made our journey much easier. WOMMA has given PEMCO access to strategic thinkers, experienced practitioners, and incredibly valuable colleagues on the front lines of customer engagement. Our WOMMA membership has been incredibly valuable.
As the 2011 WOMMA Board President, I’m excited by the goals we have established for the coming year.
- We’ll continue to differentiate ourselves from other organizations through our increasing focus on advocacy for the discipline of credible word-of-mouth marketing, both online and offline.
- We’ll strengthen our ethics code, our role with the Federal Trade Commission, and our continually improving research and educational resources for members.
- We’ll strive to increasingly serve the entirety of our member’s WOM needs throughout their business: Customer Service, Legal, HR, Product Development, and of course, Marketing and PR.
- We’re committed to seeking new and valuable ways to increase the ROI on the membership investments we all make.
- We’ll do more to bring the WOMMA experience to your marketplace – a particular interest of mine. In 2011, WOMMA will host regional events that enable us to share our story with communities of members and potential members where they live, work, learn, and TALK.
If you find your organization struggling on the traditional media battlefield, and like PEMCO you would like to be prepared with new ammunition, I’d like to encourage you to join WOMMA right away. I can say with confidence that it has made a difference. I believe that WOMMA can help you too!



